Limited Morphological Differences of Brown Anoles (Anolis sagrei) between Their Native Cuban and Invasive Florida Range

Jars containing museum specimens are on a cart next to the shelf.

The ubiquity of Brown Anoles (Anolis sagrei) in Florida means that they are constantly on my mind. Given the proposition that rapid evolution may be important to invasive species success, I was curious to determine if invasive Brown Anoles in the southeastern United States, centered in Florida, have any morphological differences from Brown Anoles in their native range in Cuba. To address this question, I measured museum specimens to compare Brown Anole morphology between their invasive and native range and “go back in time” to see if Brown Anole morphology has changed since their invasion.

As reported in our recent paper, Brown Anoles have broadly similar morphology between their native Cuban and invasive Florida ranges. Additionally, we found no clear evidence of the measured morphological traits changing over time. These results suggest that rapid morphological evolution may not be essential to the success of invasive Brown Anoles.

Abstract:

Understanding why some species and not others are successful global invaders is an important question in ecology and evolutionary biology. There is much debate on the role that rapid post-invasion adaptation plays in the success of invasive species. Here, we investigated signals of rapid and broad-scale morphological evolution in Anolis sagrei (Brown Anole) between their invasive and native distributions. Although we found significant differences in a few morphological characters between invasive and native Brown Anoles, the morphological variation present in the species broadly overlapped between both populations and has not significantly changed over the last century. These results suggest the invasive success of Brown Anoles in Florida may not be due to major evolutionary change from their Cuban ancestors.

What Happens to Anoles in Hurricanes?

 

Researchers have thought of putting anoles in experimental wind tunnels. Perhaps this is the next best evidence? Or maybe this was a setup? Either way, we can see the classic anole response to falling.

h/t Mike Whitlock

A Tale of Many-Tailed Anoles and Many Other Tails

Anolis sagrei from the Bahamas

A dozen years ago, Jonathan Losos explained in these pages how lizards sometimes end up with multiple tail tips, a phenomenon known as tail furcations. My student Tim Baum and I recently published a review of this phenomenon for all lizards and found that published reports of tail furcations exist for 250 species! For the readers of Anole Annals, I wanted to present a quick review of this phenomenon in the genus Anolis.

Among the many lizard records we located were only ten species of Anolis (4% of the total), slightly below the expected proportion of Anolis out of all lizards (6%). But these anoles do have a nice variety of multi-tails! Overall, they conform to the concept that two tails are the most common occurrence (64% of known anole cases). Two-tailed lizards can be divided into those who have a forked tail that is less than half the tail length (i.e., the extra tail starts nearer the tail’s end), which is known as a bifurcation. The other option is that the additional tail begins closer to the beginning of the tail, and this is known as a duplication. Duplications are relatively rare in Anolis, with only 22% of the two tails originating close to the body.

What is interesting about anoles is that aside from two-tailed lizards, three tails are known from Anolis equestris and A. grahami, and there is even a four-tailed A. sagrei! Most lizard genera stick with the two-tailed version, so anoles have it going on!

Clearly, with well over 400 species of Anolis listed in the Reptile Database (and I don’t want to quibble about genus assignments here), many more species should be out there with furcated tails. Based on our research and literature review, these encounters are serendipities of fieldwork, so keep your eyes open and mobile phone cameras ready – and then publish the new records!

Help The Reptiles of Ecuador Get Published!

Hear about what’s need here.

And here’s the story behind the book.

Forbes Promotes New Colombian Guide to Anoles

from the pages of Forbes:

How Do You Tell Colombia’s Bright, Zany Anole Lizards Apart?

Updated Jul 9, 2024, 10:27am EDT

A group of passionate lizard scientists have published a guide to the dozens of species of Anolis: small, brightly-coloured tree lizards related to iguanas. Colombia holds more than 75 species of Anolis which are and males have large throat fans called dewlaps, to attract females.

Camilo Andrés Estupiñan, a biologist at Icesi University in Colombia and a researcher at the Interandinos Foundation, is currently leading a project to create an illustrated guide of Anolis in Colombia. “Colombia has the greatest diversity of Anolis species in the world, and this book seeks to capture and share that richness,” he says, adding that this is a collaborative effort that came out of the Interandinos Foundation.

“The information available on these species is quite scattered, which represents a great challenge for us, but we have received incredible support from the scientific community, who have contributed significantly,” he says, “Maria, the illustrator of this book, has done an exceptional job, exceeding our expectations with illustrations that accurately capture the unique characteristics of each species.”

Estupiñan explains that this project is crucial not only for biodiversity conservation, but also for fostering knowledge and appreciation of our rich biodiversity, empowering local communities.

“We hope that this book will not be the last of its kind, but will open the doors for future scientific dissemination projects on reptiles in Colombia, contributing to a deeper knowledge and greater conservation of these species,” he says.

Estupiñan explains that in Colombia, local communities such as farmers and indigenous people are “true guardians of the forests” and have direct and constant contact with natural resources.

“They see biodiversity not only as a resource to be conserved, but as part of their identity and can provide valuable data that enriches science,” he says, “In this context, projects such as the Anolis illustrated guide are fundamental, as they not only promote the knowledge and conservation of biodiversity, but also empower these communities.”

Passion For Colombia’s Lizards

Estupiñan was born and raised in Cali, Colombia and says as a child he has always had a deep passion for reptiles. “This passion led me to study biology at Icesi University, where I was fortunate to meet Jhan Carlos Salazar, who was finishing his thesis on the physiology of Anolis lizards,” he says, “He took me to do field work and introduced me to these fascinating lizards, which further ignited my passion for them.”

Estupiñan would go to to start a master’s degree in engineering and teaching undergraduate conservation biology.

“With a clear vision of contributing significantly to research, environmental education and scientific dissemination in Colombia, I founded together with some colleagues and friends the Interandinos Foundation,” he says, “Since its creation, the foundation has allowed me to channel my passion for nature and science into concrete actions that have a real impact on our community and beyond.”

Estupiñan explains that scientists from the Global South bring a deep understanding of their own ecological, social and economic contexts, which is essential for developing sustainable and effective solutions to problems that affect both locally and globally.

“This proximity not only allows for greater precision in identifying problems, but also facilitates the implementation of solutions that are culturally and environmentally appropriate,” he says, “Ultimately, integrating these voices and perspectives into global science is not only right, but also essential to effectively address the environmental, social and developmental challenges we face today.”

More Passion for Anoles

Biologist Jhan Salazar, who is also a collaborator on the illustrated guide, graduated from the Biology Program in 2018 from Icesi University, in Cali, in the south of Colombia and is now pursuing his PhD in Evolution, Ecology and Population Biology at the Washington University in St. Louis.

“My research is focused on Anolis lizards now, but I want to study other lizard genres, snakes, and frogs in the future,” he says, adding that his passion for studying reptiles started back when he was growing up in the country-side of Cauca, Colombia.

“We grew up surrounded by nature and when I was 11, I went out with my family we went on a trip and that really influenced me,” he says, “Its a rural zone and a forested zone.”

In 2019, he was also announced as the winner of the Young Afro-Colombian 2019.

Following the Expansion of Anolis sagrei in Ecuador

While reading reports on the colonization events of the brown anole and its impacts on local fauna, I never thought I would have the chance to see this lizard, so interesting from an ecological point of view, in the wild. However, years ago, thanks to an invitation from a colleague in Guayaquil, I participated in the first report of the occurrence of Anolis sagrei in Ecuador. At that time, only a few individuals were seen, and encounters were casual in two specific locations. However, since 2018, I have had the opportunity to start monitoring the brown anole in Guayaquil, Guayas province.

In past experiences searching for native anoles over five years in forests and other vegetation formations in Ecuador, I knew the local anoles are animals that hide a lot and are not seen frequently. I was used to recording few encounters over long distances (finding five or at best 10 individuals after several days and nights of searching). To my surprise, the scenario changed in Guayas. During our first excursion, we found more than ten individuals in five minutes within an area of five square meters in the middle of the city. These animals did not hide or try to escape; instead, they initiated displays.

This marked the beginning of our efforts to search for them not only in the areas reported by Amador et al. (2017) but also in various places throughout the city. This included garden areas and urban parks, as well as remnants of forest found in the city’s outskirts. Thanks to these observations, we gathered information on their diet, behavioral activity, and ecology, which will surely help us understand why they are so successful in these environments.

In this study, we managed to report not only the sites where we personally searched but also incorporated casual observations from citizens using citizen science tools like iNaturalist. Thanks to this, we now know that the species has spread to different provinces in the country (Esmeraldas and Manabí provinces), including one in the Amazon region (Orellana province). It’s interesting that thanks to this tool, we included points where we would not have thought to look for them. Additionally, the brown anole is very charismatic, and many people have felt an affinity and attraction to the little creatures that move their dewlaps, hence fortunately, the records provided by citizens were of good quality, allowing us to corroborate identification and data accuracy.

The adaptability of this lizard is evident in its ability to occupy different spaces, including urban areas such as parks, gardens, and natural areas along riverbanks. Consequently, new questions arise: where did these animals come from? How long ago did they arrive? Does their current distribution result from one or multiple introduction events? What impact will this lizard have on local species in terms of displacement or competition? We know it is a dominant species, but we still lack indications of its effect, particularly in Isla Santay reserve, where two other native species are found in sympatry (Cruz-García et al. 2023). Since we registered that several families of insects that are considered agricultural pests are part of their diet, may they have a positive or negative impact on humans? (Narvaez et al. 2020)

We feel obligated to review how the dispersal processes of this lizard can be controlled. However, more information on the species’ actions is needed to start recommending control measures or other actions at the local level. These lizards have been found in nurseries around the city, which are also used to support reforestation efforts in areas of native vegetation, facilitating the dispersal processes and the possible ecological consequences associated with their spread.

In sum, we have a love-hate relationship with the brown anole. As behavioral ecologists, we recognize that Anolis sagrei represents an excellent model for studying the biological invasion process, and we hope to share more about our findings from the past seven years soon. However, we are also concerned about how to manage this species. Probably, containment or eradication measures may need to be established to prevent problems experienced in other regions from occurring with Ecuadorian anoles.

We want to share our experience with other enthusiasts of this fascinating invader and our efforts to understand its dispersal mechanisms, ecological and behavioral adaptations, and the strategies suggested for its management. By doing so, we hope to collaborate and contribute to a broader understanding and effective management of the brown anole.

You can read the full article here.

I would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution of Fernando Ayala-Varela to this blog.

REFERENCES

Amador, L., Ayala-Varela, F., Nárvaez, A. E., Cruz, K., & Torres-Carvajal, O. (2017). First record of the invasive brown anole, Anolis sagrei Duméril & Bibron, 1837 (squamata: iguanidae: dactyloinae), in South America. Check List13(2), 2083-2083.

Cruz-García, K., Barreno, M., Cuadrado, S., Moretta-Urdiales, M. D. M., Molina-Moreira, N., Salas, J. A., … & Narváez, A. E. (2023). Amphibians and reptiles of Isla Santay (Durán, Ecuador). Check List19(3), 347-369.

Narváez, A. E., Ghia, T., Moretta-Urdiales, M. M., & Moreira, N. M. (2020). Feeding habits of Anolis sagrei, an introduced species, in urban ecosystems of Guayas Province. Urban Ecosystems23(6), 1371-1376.

Narváez, A. E., Ayala-Varela, F., Cuadrado, S., Cruz-García, K., Yánez-Muñoz, M. H., & Amador, L. (2024). Updated distribution of the brown anole in continental Ecuador: a case of urban spaces favoring the establishment of an opportunistic exotic species. BioInvasions Records13(2), 373-384.

 

 

Introducing the illustrated Field Guide to the Anolis Lizards of Colombia

Hey fellow Anole lovers!

We are a group of passionate Colombians who are absolutely fascinated by Anolis lizards. You know, those charming little reptiles with their vibrant dewlaps and incredible diversity. And let’s be honest, who needs geckos when you’ve got Anoles? (Just kidding, gecko fans – we love them too, but anoles have a special place in our hearts!)

The Birth of a Dream

Our journey began with a simple idea: to create a comprehensive, visually stunning field guide that captures the beauty and diversity of Anolis lizards in Colombia. With over 80 species in our biodiverse country, we knew this would be no small feat, but we were up for the challenge!

Imagine flipping through pages filled with beautiful illustrations, detailed maps showing where each species can be found, and handy tips on how to tell them apart from their look-alikes. That’s exactly what we’re creating – a guide that’s not only informative but also a joy to use.

The Magic of Illustrations

One of the coolest aspects of our field guide is the artwork. Each species will have detailed illustrations of adult males and females, all in their characteristic poses. Our talented illustrator is working hard to bring these lizards to life on the page. Here’s a sneak peek at how the book will look:

Why It Matters

Colombia is bursting with all kinds of amazing wildlife, and Anolis lizards are a big part of what makes our nature so special. This guide isn’t just a book; it’s a tool for education, conservation, and accurate taxonomy. By highlighting these incredible lizards, we hope to foster a deeper appreciation and understanding of our natural heritage and make identifying these species easier and more precise for everyone.

How You Can Get Involved

We have an exciting way for you to support our project – Adopt a Species! Here’s how it works:

  • Pick Your Favorite Anole: For a $50 donation, you can sponsor a species of your choice.
  • Get Your Name in the Book: Your name will appear on the species page as its sponsor.
  • Receive Exclusive Perks: You’ll get a certificate and a digital illustration of the species you adopt.

Your contribution will help us bring this guide to life and support the conservation and study of these wonderful creatures. And for research labs, institutions, and universities that want to donate larger amounts, we’d love to include your logos backing the book. It’s a great way to show your support for biodiversity and conservation.

Join us on This Journey

We’re calling on all anole fans, researchers, and conservationists to join us. Whether you’re a university, research lab, or just someone who loves these lizards as much as we do, your support means the world to us. Want to get involved or learn more? Reach out to us!

Thank you for being a part of this exciting journey. Let’s celebrate the amazing diversity of Anolis lizards in Colombia together!

Happy herping!

You can contact us at:

fundacioninterandinos@gmail.com

camiloestupinan12@gmail.com

Camilo A. Estupiñan

Fundación Interandinos
Universidad Icesi

Getting Anole Research “Out There”: New Book on Anole Lizard Research for Schoolkids

 

I enjoyed visiting with anole researchers for my book “The Lizard Scientists” so much that I wanted to give nonscientists an example of the hard work it takes to learn about how Nature functions. I focused on James Stroud’s research as a good illustration of “what it takes” to study Nature in meaningful ways. Take a look at DorothyPatent.substack.com for ‘How Scientists “Do” Science’ and pass it on.

I’m now living on Kaua’i, where A. sagrei thrives in a number of environments. For example, I see almost totally black individuals on the long black volcanic rock walls along a walking path and long-tailed basically brown ones with a bright yellowish stripe along their backs along the paths bordered by dense vegetation. I know they can modify their colors depending on the background, but still, It looks to me like what one might call “secondary evolution” is going on.

Have Invasive Anoles (and Basilisks and Agamas) Been Commercialized?

Anolis cybotes from Florida. Photo by Janson Jones. https://floridensis.com/tag/anolis-cybotes/

Subrata Das writes:

The area of my interest is the commercialization of invasive species for leather, meat, hair, fur, bristles and by-products.

Of late I am researching invasive anoles, agamas and basilisks and the various ways they have been or are being commercialized in trade and commerce.

I will be deeply grateful for all information you can share with me on the commercial exploitation of anoles, agamas and basilisks in both their native and invasive ranges.

Mapping Anole Operative Temperature with Unoccupied Aerial Vehicles (UAVs)

Left: Emma setting up the 3D Anolis replicas (excuse the yoga clothes–it was hot!), Right: 3D replica in-situ.

A lot of us have been there…. setting up what seems like endless 3D anole replicas, often in the tropical heat, messing around with countless iButtons (which are a nightmare to get out of the replicas), to measure operative temperature (Te)–the temperature of the animal at equilibrium with its environment….

As frustrating as this can sometimes be, it is an integral part of measuring thermal habitat quality and availability, which as we all know, is important for such things as ectotherm energetics, abundance and predicting species responses to climate and land cover change.

However, using these 3D replicas, we only get point-based measures of Te at randomly selected points within the survey area. These points are sampling only a very small extent of thermal habitat, and therefore may not represent the conditions mere metres away.  This method therefore does not allow us to measure Te across the whole of the survey area at spatial resolutions relevant to the individual animal. This method is also, costly in terms of both time and money. Therefore, is there another way?

Well, we do have microclimate–biophysical modelling, which generally relies on mechanistic models that downscale broad scale (usually monthly) macro-climate (≥ 1km grid) data to estimate microclimate in specific habitats, e.g.  NicheMapR, Microclima and Microclimc (Kearney and Porter, 2017; Maclean et al., 2018; Maclean and Klinges, 2021). These estimates of microclimate must then be combined with biophysical heat exchange models to estimate animal operative temperature (Te), e.g. the ectotherm model in NicheMapR (Kearney and Porter, 2020).

These models have revolutionized our ability to model thermal environments across broad spatial extents, especially for species distribution modelling, and new developments have the potential to model much finer variation (e.g. Microclimc), but applications at scales of individual organismal movement (e.g. cms to m) are still rare.

These limitations of existing methods are particularly pertinent given the established importance of spatial heterogeneity of thermal environment for species, particularly ectotherms, and by extension our beloved anoles (Huey, 1974; Sears and Angiletta, 2015; Sears et al., 2016).

Luckily, we as a team had already pondered, if the canopy is key for regulating ectotherm operative temperatures (Te), then, can we predict Te using biophysical equations relating to canopy characteristics?

Part of the field team, helping process what is certainly not an anole, whilst setting up survey plots (photo credit Adam Algar).

This was the basis of this paper, “Unoccupied Aerial Vehicles as a Tool to Map Lizard Operative Temperature in Tropical Environments.”

So, to test this, we first needed to collect canopy data – which, for anyone who has done this type of work will agree, is not so easy! This is where Unoccupied Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) come in.

Page 2 of 297

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén