Anole Annals

Seaweed washed ashore on a Bahamian island. Photo by Dave Spiller.

Ecologists are increasingly recognizing the myriad connections not only among species within an ecosystem, but between species in different ecosystems. Case in point: seaweed often washes ashore, and it affects leaves on the plants found near the shoreline. How’s that, you might ask? Well, the seaweed decays and releases nutrients that act as fertilizer, increasing the growth of land plants. That’s good for the plants, but it also makes their leaves more tasty, and hence plant-eating insects are attracted and cause more damage to the leaves.

That seems straightforward enough, but then it gets more complicated. As the seaweed decays, it attracts lots of insects. And the insects, in turn, attract lizards. And, in fact, if you happen to be studying this process on small islands in the Bahamas, as Jonah Piovia-Scott and a team from UC-Davis were, then those lizards are our favorites, brown anoles. And if there are more brown anoles around, then they’ll eat more of the herbivorous insects that plague the land plants, and so the washed-up seaweed actually decrease the damage to land plant leaves, thanks to the helpful consumption of the anoles.

Except…maybe the lizards will be so delighted by the seaweed that they’ll spend all of their time there, eating the insects on the seaweed, and thus neglecting the insects on the landplants, so now the effect of seaweed on the land plants becomes negative again.

So which is it? That’s what Piovia-Scott et al. set out to discover, and they’ve just reported the results in a paper in Oecologia. And the diagram to the left explains it succinctly. Seaweed increases nitrogen in the leaves, which increases herbivory. Seaweed also increases lizard density, which decreases herbivory, though the negative effect isn’t as great as the positive effect of the nitrogen. Moreover, seaweed also causes lizards to shift their diet, which has a small (and statistically non-significant) positive effect on herbivory because the lizards aren’t eating as many of the land plant herbivores. Bottom line: seaweed increases leaf damage; lizards can’t prevent it, in part because their effects are schizophrenic: more lizards, but eating fewer herbivores.

Interestingly, these results are opposite of what the same team of authors found in a study we discussed two years ago. The difference was that in that study, a big pile of seaweed was laid out at one time and the results were followed over a short period, whereas this study followed natural seaweed deposition and compared sites differing in the amount of seaweed washed ashore, following their sites for a lengthier period of time.

One last point: how did the researchers document that the lizards were switching diet? Not from sitting around and watching the lizards, but by measuring the carbon isotope ratios in their tails. Marine vegetation tends to have higher ratios of Carbon-13 than terrestrial sources, and so insects feeding on plants from different areas will, in turn, have different ratios, which means that, in turn, one can look at the Carbon-13 ratios in lizard tissue and get a sense of from which ecosystem they’re deriving their carbon. And in this case, the more seaweed, the higher the ratio. Pretty nifty!

Anolis ginaelisae

Six large anoles of the Dactyloa clade occur in western Panama. In their explorations, Lotzkat and colleagues have collected all of them, and have just published a paper in Zootaxa reviewing these species. Their phylogenetic analyses based both on DNA and morphological characters confirm the existence of the six taxa, but also find geographically-oriented genetic differentiation in two species. In combination with morphological data, the authors split A. microtus into two species, the new one under the name A. ginaelisae.

The paper includes a nice review of all the species including spiffy color plates (see A. ibanezi below as an example) and natural history notes (short take: they’re all arboreal and almost all individuals have been caught at night). A key is also included.

Anolis ibanezi

One last note. The derivation of the new specific epithet gianaelisae is touching: “Sebastian Lotzkat dedicates this exceptionally beautiful new species to his even more enchanting fiancée Gina Elisa Moog, who has made more than a third of his life worthwhile by now, in deepest gratitude for that wonderful time and pleasant anticipation of a mutual future.”

Abstract: “Six species of giant alpha anoles of the genus Dactyloa are known to occur in western Panama: Dactyloa casildae, D. frenata, D. ibanezi, D. insignis, D. kunayalae, and D. microtus. Based on own material collected along the highlands in Bocas del Toro, Chiriquí, and Veraguas provinces and the Comarca Ngöbe-Buglé of western Panama, we review their variation in morphological characters and the 16S rRNA mitochondrial gene. Our results support all six nominal taxa, but reveal considerable genetic differentiation between populations of the two highland species, D. casildae and D. microtus, respectively, from different localities. Correlated morphological differences confirm the existence of a cryptic species among populations currently assigned to D. microtus, which we describe as Dactyloa ginaelisae sp. nov. We provide point distribution maps, morphology and color descriptions, photographs in life, conservation status assessments, and an identification key for all seven species.”

Anolis homolechis

From 2009, we have investigated the evolution and ecology of Anolis lizards in Cuba, collaborating with Habana University and The National Museum and Natural History of Cuba. Prof. Losos asked us to describe our research projects in Cuba for communication among anole biologists. Thus, we would like to inform our ongoing projects on Anolis lizards in Cuba, and we are very grateful if you have any suggestions and comments on our projects. Also, your suggestion of collaborating research projects will be welcome.

1. Searching for the genetic basis determining differences in hindlimb length between the trunk-ground anole A. sagrei and the twig anole A. angusticeps. Similar to Sanger et al. (2012), we have tried to determine the developmental timing for divergence of hindlimb length between twig and trunk-ground anoles. The manuscript on this subject was submitted and is now under review.

2.  The effects of microhabitat use, range expansion and the number of speciation events on local species richness of trunk-ground Anolis lizards in Cuba. We examined the species richness and thermal microhabitat partitioning (considered to be a measure of ecological interaction) of 12 trunk-ground anole species in 11 local assemblages in Cuba, covering nearly the entire geographic range of all these species. Our results suggest that the species composition and richness in local assemblages could be explained by both evolutionary history (the number of speciation events and limits to range expansion) and ecological processes (habitat partitioning). This research is a part of Ph.D. thesis of Antonio Cadiz (Tohoku University and Havana University). The manuscript on this subject was accepted by Ecosphere and will be available soon.

3. We reconstructed a phylogeny using almost all Cuban Anolis lizards and also analyzed the genetic distances between populations within Cuban islands for these species. This project aims not only to construct the comprehensive phylogeny, but to understand ecomorph evolution within Cuban island.

4. Genetic basis for adaptation to different thermal environments. Multiple trunk-ground species can coexist since they inhabit different thermal environments. Anolis sagrei was found in open locations with high levels of light intensity and temperature. In contrast, A. allogus was found in shaded locations within forests with low levels of both light and temperature. Anolis homolechis was typically found at the edges of forests or in open locations in forests with intermediate environmental conditions. We try to examine genetic basis for these different thermal adaptation by using both  a candidate gene approach and whole transcriptome analysis.

5. Other research projects will be started this year, although we do not specify the detailed plan.

In addition to Cuban Anoles, we are investigating the evolution of Anolis carolinensis introduced into the Bonin islands (Ogasawara islands) about 50 years ago (from either Guam, Hawaii or Florida).

Masakado Kawata, Graduate School of Life Sciences, Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan (kawata ‘at’ m.tohoku.ac.jp)